Skip to main content
On Demand

When Can Tribal Nations Sue? Theories of Standing in Federal Court


Total Credits: 1 CLE

Average Rating:
   21
Categories:
Indian Law
Faculty:
Doreen Nanibaa McPaul |  Paul Spruhan |  Harrison William Rice
Format:
Audio and Video
Original Program Date:
Apr 23, 2025


Description

The seminar explores the legal theories of standing for tribal governments in federal court.  It will examine:

    • Key cases, 
    • Jurisdictional challenges, and 
    • The evolving legal landscape that determines when and how tribal nations can bring claims. 

Attendees will gain insights into sovereignty, procedural hurdles, and strategic considerations for litigation.
 
Faculty: 

Paul Spruhan, Visiting Assistant Professor, University of New Mexico School of Law

Chairpersons
Doreen N. McPaul, President, Tribal In-House Counsel Association
Harrison Rice, Assistant Attorney General, Tohono O'odham Nation

Handouts

Faculty

Doreen Nanibaa McPaul Related Seminars and Products



is an enrolled member of the Navajo Nation. She is a 1995 graduate of Princeton University and earned her Juris Doctorate in 2001 from the Arizona State University College of Law, where she also received a Certificate in Federal Indian Law and served as a staff writer for the ASU Law Journal. After law school, Ms. McPaul clerked at the Arizona Court of Appeals for the Honorable Jefferson L. Lankford (retired). She has diverse experience serving as a tribal court staff attorney, as an associate attorney at the Nordhaus Law Firm in Albuquerque, and as a visiting clinical law professor and Interim Director of the Indian Legal Clinic at ASU. Since 2008, Ms. McPaul has worked as an in-house tribal attorney for several Arizona tribes, including a 4-year appointment as the Navajo Nation Attorney General. She currently serves as the Deputy Attorney General for the White Mountain Apache Tribe. Ms. McPaul has over 20 years of experience practicing Indian law, and is admitted to practice law in Arizona and New Mexico, as well as before several tribal and federal courts. Ms. McPaul is active in the State Bar and Indian legal community. She serves on the State Bar of Arizona Board of Governors and is currently the Vice President of the State Bar. Ms. McPaul is a founding board member of the Tribal In-House Counsel Association and served as TICA’s President for a decade. She also serves on the Board of the American Indian Law Center and was elected to membership in The American Law Institute in 2021. Most importantly, Ms. McPaul is a proud military spouse and mom. She is married to SFC Mark McPaul (retired) and they have three sons.


Paul Spruhan Related Seminars and Products

Navajo Nation Department of Justice


is Visiting Assistant Professor in the Law and Indigenous Peoples Program at the University of New Mexico School of Law. From October 2008 to October 2024, he was Assistant Attorney General at the Navajo Nation Department of Justice in Window Rock, Arizona. In that capacity, he litigated civil cases in federal, Navajo Nation, and state courts on a wide range of issues, including tribal sovereignty, environmental regulation, and labor and employment. He also drafted and negotiated contracts and intergovernmental agreements with private parties and state and federal agencies. He received his A.B. in 1995 and his A.M. in 1996 from the University of Chicago. He received his J.D. in 2000 from the University of New Mexico. He and his wife, Bidtah Becker, have two children and live in Fort Defiance on the Navajo Nation.



Reviews

5
4
3
2
1

Overall:      4.8

Total Reviews: 21

Comments

Larry R

"Good analysis of standing"

Anne A

"good information - presenter may have used too many colloquialisms interjected in the substance of the teaching."

Amy R

"The slides were wordy but also packed with info. Prof. Spruhan was excellent and funny. And I like the mural story. I will think of it when I think of standing now."

Francesca S

"Paul did great. He’s an interesting speaker and provides a lot of useful information."

Robert H

"Highly knowledgeable"

Michael H

"Great content and energy!"

Daniel R

"Harrison Rice did not present."

Frank W

"Excellent outline and discussion on the criteria to establish "Standing" "

Clayton F

"very informative. "

Joan B

"Paul was very animated and funny. He was enjoyable to listen to and helped us navigate the dry, brittle maze of federal Indian law. Thank you!"